Delphi, Indiana – A jury in Indiana reached a verdict after three days of deliberation, finding Richard Allen guilty in the murders of two teenage girls who went missing during a hike in Delphi in 2017. The jury of seven women and five men spent approximately 19 hours deliberating before convicting Allen, 52, on all charges related to the deaths of Liberty “Libby” German, 14, and Abigail “Abby” Williams, 13.
Legal experts, like Indianapolis defense attorney John Thompkins, expressed surprise at the verdict, citing concerns about the evidence and weaknesses in the state’s case. Thompkins shared that based on the information presented, a not guilty verdict seemed plausible. Allen, visibly pale and wide-eyed, had his Bible with him during the verdict announcement and showed little reaction, later turning to his family seeking reassurance.
The sentencing for Allen has been set for December 20, facing a possible maximum of 130 years in prison. The case went to the jury following closing arguments from a lengthy trial. Prosecutors presented evidence linking Allen to the crime, including a grainy cellphone video showing him near the victims before their disappearance and multiple confessions he reportedly made.
While the defense cast doubts on Allen’s confessions, arguing his mental state due to lengthy solitary confinement, prosecutors emphasized the significance of his own admissions. Despite the lack of physical evidence directly linking Allen to the murders, prosecutors relied on his repeated confessions and behavioral patterns as incriminating factors in the case.
Throughout the trial, details emerged about Allen’s interactions after the crime, including his continued residence in Delphi and his indirect involvement in the investigation through his work at a local pharmacy. Arrested in 2022 after initially denying involvement, Allen’s confessions and physical evidence from the scene ultimately led to the charges brought against him.
The prosecution highlighted Allen’s numerous self-incriminating statements, which were reportedly made to various individuals while incarcerated. A former lead psychologist testified about Allen’s shifting narrative, indicating admissions made over time, with initial denials followed by confessions in later interactions. The defense suggested alternative theories, such as a pagan ritual sacrifice, which were not admitted as evidence in court.
As the legal process unfolds, Allen maintains his innocence and can appeal the conviction within 30 days of sentencing. The case continues to evolve, shedding light on the complexities of justice and the impact on the community affected by the tragic events in Delphi.
